Rejection of Usuli Sect Akhbari and Usulis Fatwas against Hadiths Fatwas against Matam Answer these Questions
Go to Urdu Version
Home
Tehreef Quran
Azadari
Predictions of
Reoccurence
Download Videos
Lifestyle Disciplines
Suplications
Anjumane Alavi
Letters & Replies
E BOOKS
Contact us


Date:     Thu 6 Nov 2003 18:45:30
From: " %Adrkni Ya Mahdi a.s% <
cool_heraclius@hotmail.com>
 Subject : Ya Ali Madad as
 To:       :
queries@akhbari.org

Ya Ali Madad as
Asslam-o-Alikum
actullay i am from Pakistan....i am not akhbari but i agree with urs aqaed..that is:-

Ali Un Wali Allah in Namaz & Izan..i read openly in namaz...
if akhbari momins write some books on Ali Un Wali Allah in namaz so plzz send me...bcz it is very hard problem in Pakistan bcz some MUQSREEN says that Ali Un Wali Allah in namaz is batil...i am also Zanjeer Zan...
actullay we r not ancsetors shia first we r sunnah in 1947 we became shia my Grandfather study 20 years & than became shia so then to now we read Ali Un Wali Allah in namaz & Azzan...we r not shia of Mulvi or Mujtahid means not any Mulvi made us shia ...we made shia by the DUA of Syed Peer ra....he is belong to Delhi..when my grandfather born Syed ra dua for us and when he is younger he become shia....and plzz tell me more akhbari sect websites....and give me urs msn id...and M Riaz Ul Millat sahib e mail id...

ws
Ali as Ali as
Chaudhary



Date:     Sun 4 Apr 2004   05:37:50
 From:
queries@akhbari.org
 Subject : Re: Ya Ali Madad as
 To:       : " %Adrkni Ya Mahdi a.s% <
cool_heraclius@hotmail.com>

786/202
Bismillah Hir Rahman Nir Raheem
Mohteram Chaudhary Sahab, Assalamunalaikum

All praise unto creator of Md (SW) O Aal-e-Md (SW). Durood on Md (SW) O Aal-e-Md (SW).

After reading your mail I felt that maybe you have a feeling of strangeness towards the word "Akhbari". When beliefs/ fatih (Aqeeda) is same than you can say Akhbari or Imamia or Rafzi or Jaffery or follower of Imam-e-Zamana(AS) or Tawallaii or Tabarraii or Shia Imamia Ithna Ashari- all mean same.
Regarding Akhbaris in brief, I feel it a must to clear that Usooli people who think Quran & Hadees as insufficient and have added "Seerat-e-Shaikhain" - Aql and Ijma, following in the footsteps of shaikhain's characteristics, has attached all those words/titles which introduce Us for themselves and call themselves Shia, Imamia, Ithna Ashari, Jaffery, Rafzi and made others call them so too. It was imperative (Wajib) on us to separate/ differentiate ourselves from people like them who are Shia in name sake only and to show that we a re a different Sect. We are the true Shias, Akhbari- following and practicing on Akhbar-e-Ilahiya (Quran) and Akhbar-e-Aale Md(SW) (Ahadees). "Khabr" is singular , "Akhbar" is plural. Akhbari is a relative term. For example Syeds who belong to Imam Jaffer-e-Sadiq (AS)'s lineage are called Jaffery, Imam Raza(AS)'s lineage -razvi etc..Similarly we practicing on Akhbar-e-Ilahiya & Masoomeen(AS) are Akhbaris. Not only in Azaan, Aqaama, Namaz but look at all those situations/instances where saying "Ali an Waliullah (AS)" is Wajib.
1.Hadees of Imam Jaffer-e-Sadiq(AS):-whoever says "La ilaha illal la, Mohamadd(SW) an Rasool Allah" then "Ali (as)an Waliullah" is wajib on him. meaning by saying "La ilaha illal la, Mohamadd(SW) an Rasool Allah"he is making "Ali(as) an Waliullah" wajib on himself. If it is difficult for anyone to say "Ali (as)an Waliullah" then you better tell him not to say "La ilaha illal la, Mohammad(SW) an Rasool Allah" because the moment you say these two Kalemas the third kalema as per Masoom(as)'s saying automatically becomes Wajib, whatever/whichever situation/place- Minmbar, Majlis, Mehraab or Musalla.

2. Tashahhud:- Here is Tashahhud which Imam Jaffer-e-Sadiq(as) used to recite:-
Bismillahey wa billahey wal hamdo lillahey wa khairul asma' aey kulleha lillaahey Ashhaddo an la ilaha illal laaho wahdahoo la shareeka lahoo wa ashhado anna Mohammadan abdahoo wa Rasoolahoo arsalahu bil haqqey basheeraun wa nazeeraun baina yada ii sa'atey wa ashahdoanna rabbi naemarrabbo wa anna Mohammadan naemar Rasoolo wa anna Aliyan naemal wasi wa naemal Imam allahumma swaley ala Mohammadan wa aale Mohammad(SW) wa taqabbal shifaatah fi ummateh wa arfa'a dara jatehi alhamdo lillahey rabbil aalameen.

3.Refer "Tohfatul Awam" by Tasadduq Hussain sahab(RA):-
Saying of Ali (AS) an Waliullah in Azaan is considered as Bidath by Sunnis and most of the Shias doubt too and consider it as bidath also and say that in Azaan 'Ali(AS) an Waliullah' is not included but can be said as "Tabarruk" so that there is distinction between Sunnis & Shias. Inspite of it being proven fact that due to oppression by Bani Umayya even "Hayyala Khairil Amal" was taken out from Azaan than how "Ali(AS) an Waliullah" would have remained? In the name of Ali(AS) friends of Ali(AS) used to be killed due to enmity with Hzt.Ali(AS) 10 Imams (AS) were martyred how Shias could have taken Ali(AS)'s name in Azan? But it is proved from Ahadees that Ali(AS) an waliullah is an INTEGRAL part of Azaan & Aqamath. It is there in the Hadees that where "La ilaha illal Lah" is said say Mohammad(SW) an Rasool Allah and where Mohammad(SW) an Rasool Allah is said say Ali(AS) an Waliullah.

Rasool(SW) says:- Where you give my Shahadath disclose there Ali(AS) 's Wilayat too. And Also said, if one separates Me & Ali(AS) even to the extent of word "Ala" then such a person will not receive my Shifa'at.
In the book "Lawamah" Janab Ammar(RA) says- It was asked to Imam Jaffer-e-Sadiq(AS) whether Azan by non-ithna ashari is correct? Imam(AS) replied No, his azan is not correct. Thus it is proved that since in non-ithna ashari's azan there is no mention of Hzt.Ali(AS) this is why it is termed as incorrect.
It is there in Hadees that Hzt.Mohammed(SW) & Hzt.ALi(AS) are born from singular "Noor" , one got Nabuwat and one Imamat by Allah. Their soul & spirit is one and in any place separation cannot be imagined. How does one's common sense accept that half Noor's Shahadath is Jayez and other half's Shahadath Bidath!
This misapprehension is because of those people(deendar) who say that Ali(AS) an waliullah in azaan if taken as Juz(integral part) is Bidath but if taken as Tabarruk is okay.Now, this is against Shara'a to say that for a "Amr'(matter) which is bidath saying the same as tabarruk is alright. How can it be so? Bidath is that Amr which is not proved by Ahadees. it is there in Hadees that except Wilayat no other Amr is Maqbool. It is apparent and proved that Hayya alas salat & Hayya alal falah & Qadqamatis Salat which form an integral part of Azan & Aqama, neither their Buzurgi nor their Sharaf is proved .Only thing is obeying Nabi(SW)'s order. They being an integral part is right and reciting them is not Bidath only Ali(AS) an Waliullah is bidath !! Noor-e-Khuda and Rasool(SW)'s successor is Alamat (indicator) of Imaan disclosing this, is, an integral part of Azan and how can it be bidath? But calling it as tabarruk by their own invention is against Shara'a.

Wasalam
Syed Waheed Uddin Hyder Jaffery Akhbari


 Date:     Tue 9 March 2004   14:27:23
 From: " meesam ali <
meesam110@yahoo.com>
 Subject : baiat of abubakr
 To:
saelebabulyaqeen@akhbari.org

salam alykum
 respected brothers in iman plz send 4me proofs that imam ali(as) is not done baiat of abubakr... this is very imoprtant issue in our country... there r some shia n some of lanati maulana who belive that imam ali(as) make bayat of abubakar lanati... so plz send me proof that he(as) not done that... jazakomullaho khayral jaza

 thanks
 sayed meesam ali moosavi

 Date:     Mon 29 March 2004   02:32:50
 From:
saelebabulyaqeen@akhbari.org
 Subject : baiat of abubakr
 To: " meesam ali <
meesam110@yahoo.com>
Bismillah Hir Rahman Nir Raheem Mr.Meesam Ali Moosavi,
Alaikum Salaam,

All praise unto Allah and Yadullah.
Due to the mourning days, reply got late.
Moulvi, Moulana, Mulla or Mujtahid--- make them read "Kalema", complete answer lies in it. "La ilaha illal la, Mohammaden(SW) Rasool Allah, Ali(AS) an waliullah, Wasi-e-RasoolAllah(sw) wa khalifatahu bila fasl"--------when we say Ali-e-Wali(AS) as consecutive Successor (bila fasl Khalifa) then three get rejected automatically.
Bayat (= oath of allegiance) of Rasool(SW) is Bayat with Allah---------the same Rasool(SW) called Ali(AS) "Yadullah" (Allah's hands). And when one's hands have been referred as Allah's how can he do Bayat of one Fasiq & Fajir (=sinful, impious & profane)!
Some of the Ayats of Sura-e-Barat were touched by Abubakr, Ali(AS) being Ba-aey-Bismillah, Allah removed Bismillah hir Rehman nir Raheem from that sura. When so much care being taken for Quran-e-Saamit (Silent Quran) then how is it possible that Quran-e-Natiq (talking Quran) Ali Ibne Abi Talib(AS) will do Bayat of Fasiqh?? Astaghfirullah.

Here are the Proofs in support of above:-
1.Sura-e-Fatah:-
Innal lazeena yuba yeaunaka innama yuba yeaunallah yadullahey fouqha aidayhim faman nakasa fa innama yankusu ala nafsehi wa man au fa bema aahada alaihullah fasa yutehi ajran azeeman.

Translation:- (Aye Rasool,SW) Those who do Bayat of you actually do it of Allah. It is Allah's hand on their hands. Then those who break (the oath), the loss will be on their own self. And those who keep (the oath) it, on which he has vowed to Allah then very soon he will also reward him in a big way.
Tafseer-e-Saafi:-The meaning of this is O' Rasool(sw) when they do bayat of you and you put your hand on their hands, there your hand is in place of Allah's hand. Because when they do bayat of you they actually do bayat of Allah.

2.Proof:- Allama majlisi in "Behaar-ul- Anwaar" has given a narration taken from "Sulaim Bin Qais Hilali":-
" We were sitting with Abdullah ibne Abbas and were grieving on Prophet(sw)'s death.Hzt.Ali Ibne Abi Taalib (as), Bani Hashim(Hashmiites clan), Salman, Meqdaad, Abuzar and few other Sahaba hadn't done bayat.
Umar told Abubakar: see except for the above mentioned, everyone else has done bayat, and these people will not do bayat until Ali(as) does.
Abubakar told Umar's uncle's son: go and tell Ali(as) that Rasool's(sw) successor is calling you. Khanfaz came and told Hzt.Ali(as) to come with him.Ali Ibne Abi Taali(as) replied: Khanfaz you are only a messenger nothing more than that, go and tell Abubakar(l) that Ali(as) is saying, you very well know that Nabi-e-Akram(sw) did not appoint you as His successor and you also very well know that who Rasool's successor is."
Thus from this above narration it is proved that Ali Ibne Abi Taalib(as) did not do bayat and bayat is done only of successor. This is the reason that we shiane Ali(as) Akhbari accept Ali-e-Wali(as) as Bilafasl Qalifa and say so in our Azaan.

Wassalaam.
Syed Waheedudin Hyder Jaffery Akhbari.


 Date:      Fri 14 Nov 2003   02:48:13
 From: " syedarshad Hasan <
sahasan_99@yahoo.com>
 Subject :
 To:
queries@akhbari.org

In my 26 Sept, 2003, emial, I had asked about the source/sources of all those books which are referred in one of the options of your web-site where a book entitled "Shaheed-e-Javed" is also mentioned. But you did not bother to give the name of that source, and in this case what is the authenticity of your total references. In my opinion you have a habit of spitting on others. 

 Syed Arshad Hasan Abidi

 
 Date:     Fri,  5 Dec  2003     01:05:35

 From:     queries@akhbari.org
Subject :Re:
To:       " syedarshad Hasan <
sahasan_99@yahoo.com>
Bismillah Hir Rahman Nir Raheem Salaamunalaikum Mr. Arshad Hasan Abidi,

Rasool(SW)'s Saying:- Those who do not begin their conversation with Salaam, do not make them sit with you and do not answer them.
Because you are visiting our Website, here are few necessary things for you:-
Reference of books should be asked by persons who have knowledge of names of Scholars, names of books and have read them too. Your way of questioning reflects that you hate Ahlebait (AS) and love Mujtahadeen. For your information & insight let me tell you that The source of the book "Shaheed-e-Jaweed" has been provided right next to its name on our website along with the telephone number & edition of the book. This shows how much you have read or are talking facts, Mr.scientist!!!!! 
The sad part is that you are writing "Abidi" along with your name and are supporting people who are belitlling your ancestors/ lineage. If someone abuses your father will you be asking references then also???
You first decide what your religion is, are you a Shia-ne-Ali(AS) or Shia-ne-osman? It will be easier for us then to answer your questions. Youre saying that we have a habit of spitting on others, meaning you are habituated to making people spit.
First cultivate yourself about the way of questioning and answering in Ilmi (Ilm= Knowledge) world.
 It is saddest to observe that till yesterday the way and the questions "Aa'ma"  used to ask, today people calling themselves Shia & Aale Rasool(SW) are asking the same questions. There has been an increase in " Daqelool Nasb" & "Qarajul Nasb" in our community, this is the reason why Ahlebait(AS)'s support is not being understood. 

 Wassalam
 Saele Babul Yaqeen
Syed Waheed uddin Hyder Jaffery AKhbari


  Date:       Fri 14 Nov 2003   13:55:04

  Subject : Thanks

  To:        queries@akhbari.org



Ya Ali  madad 

Salam  alaikum  Mr.Waheed  Bhai 

   How  are  you??  hope  fine  by  the  grace  of  almighty,  I am  from  UK,  now I'm  akhbari,  to  find  true  religion  and  the  path  to  heaven  your  sites  help  me out   much  and  my  friend ,  I'm  glad  to my  friend   as she told me  about  your  site  and  your  site  is  very  good.  I'm  the  only one  akhbari  in  my whole  family  and  trying  to  make  them,  pray  for  me.Hazrat-e-Abbas(as)  will  reward  you.  Thanks  a  lot  for  making  me  a  member  of  heaven.

 Wassalam 
BAR  MUJHTAHEDEEN  LANATH. (beyshumaar)

  Date:    :  Mon 17 Nov 2003  22:00:23
  Subject : Solve it
  To:       : queries
@akhbari.org

ya  ali  madad
 Salam  alaikum  Mr.Waheed  bhai,

     How are you? Mr. Waheed  bhai !  I'm very  confused  as  I  always  heard  in  the  speech  of  scholars  that  moula  ali  said  on 19th  Ramzan  "FUZTO  BE  RABBIL  KABA"  so  my  question  is  who can  a  superior  says  this??  as  kaba is  inferior  in  the  comparison  to  moula Ali.
   I  ask  this  same  question  to  my  akhbari  friend  she  gave  me  answer  by  the  help  of  hadees  "O  Ali!  your  status  is  kaaba  for  me".  but  still  i'm  not statisfied  with  her,  so  better   if  you  solve  my  querry. 

Thanking You 
Bar  mujhtahedin  lanath
  
 Date:    : Fri 14 Nov 2003   13:55:04
 Subject : Thanks
 From    :  queries
@akhbari.org

Bismillah Hir Rahman Nir Raheem

 Qalallah Ta' ala: - Qul Ja'al Haq WA Zahaqal Batil inal Batil Ka'ana Zahuqha
Allah Ta'ala Says: - Tell that "Haq" (Truth) has come and "Batil" (False) has been destroyed. And Batil was bound to perish. 

My Imaani Sister,
 All praise unto Khuda-e-Azali and Sahab-e-Azali.
Sincere apologies for replying so late to your mails. I am submerged in grief as I have been orphaned for two reasons. Rasool(SW) :- Your fathers are 3. One responsible for your birth, second who married his daughter to you, third who imparted knowledge to you. And Repeated thrice, this one is Afzal (superior).
Rasool(SW)'s Hadees :- Afzal ul aamaley bazlislam lil aalim.
Rasool (SW) said: - Best practice; (amal) is to try for Aalim's Well-being.
But the sad thing is even after this, I lost shelter of "behr-e-Ilm" (ocean of knowledge) , my father & teacher, over my head. "Rezan Beqaza' ehi wa tasleeman le amrehi". 
After reading your mail dated 2003, I felt very glad because a veil has been lifted from another Akhbari, because Akhbari's are not made but are born as such. The promise you made to Allah in Aalam-e-Arwah (When you were in the soul stage), that has come true. By the grace of Chaharda Masoomeen(AS) may  Maarefath & divine guidance increase for you. Ilahi Aameen. 

In the letter dated 17th November 2003 the question you asked reflects your high Imaani taste, Alhamdolillah.  I pray to Allah that as your ingenuity increases your interest and passion for gaining Marefath increases too. 
Certainly, Moula(AS) said "Fuzto be Rabbil Ka'aba". Laraib Ameerul Momeneen(AS) is superior to Ka'aba. Actually, "Ya Ali(AS) be manzilathe Ka'aba"was said because Namaaz was formed in Meraj, conditions for Namaz are many, and you must be aware of all, one of them is Fixing direction. Now what will be Ka'aba there? This is the reason why Moula Ali(AS) was referred as "Anta Bemanzilathey Ka'aba". 
On the morning of 19th of Ramzan, When our Eternal Lord/Master said, "Fuzto be rabil ka'aba" it meant that  "Swear on Lord of Ka'aba that ALi(AS) has succeeded/ attained".
Moula (AS) swore on God of Ka'aba and not on Ka'aba. 

Keeping in view your willingness to learn I am giving one Hadees on Momin's greatness and few words from Aamal-e-Hzt AMeerul momeneen(AS) to be done in the courtyard of Najaf-e-Ashraf, to strengthen my proof.
1. Hadees:- "Qalbil Momin haramallah wa haraamun ala hramallah aiyn yeleja fihey  ghairahu"
Translation:- Heart of Momin is Allah's sanctuary (the four walls of Ka'aba), and anyone              
                  
 else's entry is forbidden in it.
In Haq Religion Shia Imamia Ithna Ashari Akhbari's faith (Aqeeda) Allah does not sit anywhere but Allah's deputy's (Naiib-e-Khuda) stay is similar to it. Like Moula (AS) Zahoor In Ka'aba. 

2. Prayer to be read at Najaf-e-Ashraf's courtyard-(extract):- Allahumma inna haazal harama haramoka wal maqama maqamoka.
Aye, Allah, without doubt this Baargaah (mansion) is your Baargaah, this place (Maqaam) is your place. Its very clear that whichever is Ali(AS)'s place that will be considered as Allah's place too. 

I think your query is clear to you now but if any doubt remains please do tell me.
Again in the end i pray to Khuda that may your "Toufiqaath" increase along with long life.
Allah's & total Anmbiya's(Prophets) and Angel's (Malaika) and all Momeneen's Laanat on self proclaimed Naiib-e-Imams.

Wassalam
 Saele Babul Yaqeen Syed Waheed Uddin Hyder Jaffery Akhbari


  Date:       Tue 4 Nov 2003   15:56:45

  From:      Henje Lewe (henjelewe@yahoo.com)

  Subject : Centers In Africa

  To:        queries@akhbari.org



Salaams,

 I am an African Shia (Convert from Sunni), I came across your website that talks about 'Usooli' and 'Akhbari' - I believe I belong to the Usooli group,but I  would like know if have any centers in Africa for the Akhbaris.

Regards,
Henje.

  Date:       Mon 1 Dec 2003   08:56:37

  From:      queries@akhbari.org

  Subject : Centers In Africa

  To:        Henje Lewe (henjelewe@yahoo.com)





Bismillah Hir Rahman Nir Raheem

Mr.Henje Lewe,     Assalamunalaikum,

 Salwat on Md (SW) and Aale Md.(SW).

After reading your interesting mail, i 'd like to put across to you that, you are calling yourself a Shia but you are not one, you are only a Muslim. Refer dictionaries like "Taleem ul lughaat", Feroz ul lughaat" and other ones in this regard where it is clearly written that Akhbari is a Shia Sect, and Usooli is a Muslim Sect, who do taqleed of mujtahid. A person who writes/compiles dictionaries does so leaving any prejudices and without bias, gives the exact meaning of the words.

 There is no difference between Usooli and Sunni. Usooli's ordinance (Shariyat) source is Quran, Hadees, Aql (intellect0 and Ijma (consensus)-(see "Touziul Masael by Moulana Seestani). Similarly, Sunni's ordinance source is Quran, Hadees, Qayas (guess work) and Ijma(consensus). Apparently Qayas and Aql are two different words but Qayas is based upon Aql only.

Akhbaris deny Shaikhaini characteristic, Ijtehad (juristic expertise) and practice only on Quran & Ahlebait(AS). I live in India, how can i tell you where Akhbari centre in Africa is?? Whoever/ whichever is adherent to only Quran & Ahlebait (AS) and does Taqleed of Masoomeen (AS) only, is Akhbari/ Akhbari Centre.
 
Wassalam
 Saele Babul Yaqeen Syed Waheed uddin Hyder Jaffery Akhbari


Date        Mon 24 May 2004
From muayad muayad (muayad7253@yahoo.com)
Subject :
To:        :
queries@akhbari.org
CC :saelebabulyaqeen@akhbari.org

alsalam alekom this is muayad hussian altaei

a i'm shia moslem ... I naver her or read abut this .. I thing you my be say that by misstak in the front of the webside you have . it was in arabic language ..

brother and sister I need you to make sure abut this and ask arabic shia moslem .. so thay will told you whats wrong about .

thank you. muayad


Date       :Sun 28 Nov 2004
From      :saelebabulyaqeen@akhbari.org
Subject  :Re:
To:         muayad muayad (muayad7253@yahoo.com)

Bismillah Hir Rehman Nir Rahim

Salamun Alaikum

Untill you tell us clearly about the hadees, how will we know which one is wrong? There is apparent difference between our grammar and Ahlebait (as)'s grammar like in many of the Ayats of Holy Quran. For now i m giving you two Ayats, kindly send me their meaning and translation.

(1) SIRATO ALLAYYA MUSTAQEEM

(2) SALAMUN ALA ILYASEEN.

Wassalaam

Saele Babul Yaqeen Syed Waheeduddin Hyder jaffery Akhbari.


Date      :Mon 20 Sep 2004
From     :tremendous_judean (tremendous_judean@hotmail.com))

Subject :assalam-o-alaikum
To         :Saelebabulyaqeen@akhbari.org

 

assalam-o-alaikum mohtram waheed uddin akhbari sahab
mein shia mazhab ko apna chuka hoon magar zehan main jitnay bhi sawalat thay un kay jawab usooli hazraat say hi liay. ab choon kay aap akhbari hain aur mein bhi kafi hadd tak akhbariat ko pasand karta hoon iss liay aap say jawabat chahta hoon agar aap ijazat dain toh mein apnay aglay message main apnay sawalat puchoon. shukria

ALLAH HAFIZ and take care
Tremendous Judean

 

Date      :Wed 14 Jul 2004
From     :tremendous_judean (tremendous_judean@hotmail.com)

Subject :the changes in the holy Quran
To         :akhbariqueries@akhbari.org

cc        :saelebabulyaqeen@akhbari.org

 

Assalam-o-Alaikum
Mohtram Waheed uddin Haider Jafri Akhbari Sahab
maira naam Mohammad Abbas Haider hai aur mein aap say akhbari hazraat kay Quran main tabdeeli kay aqeeday kay hawalay say yay puchna chahta hoon kay aap log aisa kyun mantay hain kay Quranay Pak main changes ki gaee hain? jis kitaab ki hifazat khud KHUDA TALA kay APNAY zimmay hai toh aap aisa kaisay maan saktay hain kay koi mal'oon us main tabdeeli karsakta hai? jawab chahunga. ijazat dijiay shukria   ALLAH HAFIZ and take care

Tremendous_judean

 

Date      :Sun 28 Nov 2004
From     :
saelebabulyaqeen@akhbari.org
Subject :the changes in the holy Quran
To         :
tremendous_judean (tremendous_judean@hotmail.com)
 

Bismillahirrehmannirrahim

Salamun Alaikum.

Hairat is baat ki hai ke hum ye waaze kar chuke hai ke Akhbari hazraat Quran aur Ahlebait(as) ke followers hai, phir uske baad aapka ye sawaal karna ke "aap hazraat aisa kyon maantay hai?".

Agar khaul-e-Masoom(as) na hota to hum kyon maante. Aur aaj tak hum Akhbari hazraat tehreef karne waale par aur is tehreef ko na maanne waalao par mussalsal laanat karte hai.Aap ke reference ke liye quran me tehreef ki dalil di ja rahi hai.

Ayat 79 Tafseer 1 Surae Waqiya

 ''La Yamasahu...'' ... Tahzeeb ul ehkam mein Janab Imam Moosiye Kazim(AS) se manqool hai ke mushaf ko napaak honeki halat mein na chuhwa jaaye aur janb honeki halat mein na chuhwa jaye aur na latkaya jaye ke uski dori chuhwi jaye aur na uske aur mutaleqhaat. isliye ke khuda farmata hai ''la tamasahu...'' ... ehtejaaje tabresi mein hai ke jab umar abubakr ki taraf se khaleefa banaya gaya to us ne Janabe Amir(AS) se darqhaast ki ke woh Hazrat(AS) apna quran-e-majeed awaam un naas ko de dein taake un logoun mein jo quran raaej tha us se milakar dekh len. un Hazrat(AS) se guftagoo in lafzoun mein ki '' aye Abulhasan(AS) agar aap munasib jaaney to woh quran le aayein jo abubakar ke saamne laye the taake hum sab ka uspar ijtemaa ho jaaye'' . Hazrat(AS) ne farmaya: Afsos ab uske milne ka tumhare liye koi mouqha nahi hai. Abubakar ke paas usko is liye laya tha ke tum par hujjat hojaaye aur tum qayamat ke din yeh na keh sako ke tum is se bekhabar the. na yeh keh sako ke aap usey hamare paas laye na the. warna jo quran-e-majeed mere paas hai usey to siwaye mutaharoun ke yaani ausiya ke jo meri aulad se honge aur koi chooh bhi nahi sakta. Umar ne kaha aaya us ke izhaar ka koi waqt bhi muyyaan hai?   Hazrat(AS) ne farmaya : haan, maloom hai jab meri aulad mein se Qayam Aale Md(AS) qayam honge woh usko zahir bhi karenge aur sab logoun ko usi par chalayenge aur tamaam qawaid qawaneen usi ke mutabiqh jaari honge.

Wassalaam

Saelebabul Yaqeen Syed Waheeduddin Hyder Jaffery Akhbari
 


Date      :19 Jul 2004
From     :hyder mehdi (hydermehdi@rediffmail.com)

Subject :regarding taqleed
To         :Saelebabulyaqeen@akhbari.org

 salaam alaikum waheed bhai,
      i'm hyder from darushifa.Believe me i dont think akhbari'ism is wrong.Though i pretend as usooli,i do give laanat on all ayatullahs because they made maatam haraam,and i do kham zani and seena zani every year. I also do come in your majalises(may be u have seen me.)and i also came to the funeral of your father.i was in daira till the tadfeen.
what i heard that in the fatwa againts khooni maatam,no one has said it haraam.my buzurg usoolis said that the akhbaris were the people who added the word haraam so as to insult the ulemaas.Now you tell me whats the proof the ayatullahs has said it haraam .'ocos I am told by others that the word Haraam was not stated in the fatwa. its the evil work of Akhbaris in order to insult and proof ayatullahs wrong. Please reply me at your first free time.

Ps: One person has evidence of  "Taqleed-e-ghaire-Masoom". Infact a book on the same topic was written by ur father Riyaauddin sahab. If u believe me, then post your questions.

Date :23 Jul 2004

Sub :thanks giving

salaam alaikum waheed bhai,

 i too regret the demise of qibla,but i thank u for replying me. whenever u r ready just tell me.You see me and my family respect marhoom qibla alot and v dont like people criticising him.
    the main defect, one buzurg usooli said to me, that akhbaris dont do taqleed of ghair-e-masoom,but marhoom qibla had return a book on the same topic.(evidence can be shown).
         
   khudahafes

Date:25 Aug 2004

Sub : Wishes

salaam alaikum waheed bhai,
i wish u on the auspicious month of rajab.i rarely listen 2
ur majalis.but i love to hear them as u upgrade and upgrade moula.
Let me tell u something from the depth of my heart-being a shia Asna Ashari v cannot say Ali is God, but i feel overjoyed when a stranger (ghair shia) considers Ali a sGod.       
Once i heard u saying that Moula says "Anallah", this made confused so can u please at ur first free time clear my dobt. I'll be very gratefull 2 u.     
I have many doubts, Inshallah spontaneously i'll ask u. Waiting for ur reply,                    KHUDAHAFES.

PS:On special days talk about Meraj as u know there is a cancer of whabiat in our community. Many dont agree upon the hand of Ali.

Date:27 Sep 2004

Sub : y so?

dear waheed bhai,
                i dont understand y arent u not responding to me.have u forgotten my question which i asked u in the month of july.u said that u r mourning u father's death.IT'S O.K.
 but atleast tell me when u 'll reply me.Hope this time u respond me and atleast tell me the date on which u'll reply me .KHUDAHAFES.

PS:Atleast give me your Phone Number

Date:5 Oct 2004

Sub : lets make final

salaam alaikum waheed bhai,
                              regarding the query which i asked u in the month of july,u responded by saying that u r mourning your father's sad demise.o.k
so lets make it final.I hope u'll answer me after 23rd Ramzan or even later after Eed-ul-Fitr. Please dont keep me waiting for this time. KHUDAHAFES.

PS:I dont want to irritate u, so please kindly positively or negatively respond me. If u dont like to answer my queries then please let me know.

 

Date       :Sun 28 Nov 2004
To          :
hyder mehdi (hydermehdi@rediffmail.com)
From      :saelebabulyaqeen@akhbari.org

 

Bismillah Hir Rehman Nir Raheem

Salamun Alaikum

Janab Hyder Mehdi Sahab

Thank you for attending my father's funeral service.Whoever person is telling you that Qibla has written in his book that "taqleed of Ghair-e-Masoom can be done", simply ask him when he is adamant on this, then when the same Qibla told that "Taqleed of Ghair-e-Masoom is haraam" why isn't he acting upon it?

 Moreover, what will you say about Janabe Salman who was a parsi before getting the status of "MINNA".?

Coming to the other mail regarding "ANNALLAH", it is very saddening that momeneen has not understood ISM and MUSAMMA. The word Allah is ISM and not MUSAMMA because the word Allah has been formed by coming together of various alphabets, Khuda wande Aalam is MUNAZZA even from this. Its a miracle of God that he made the ISM talk, result is ANNALLAH.

For further proof refer this extract from ziarat "Assalaam alaika ya aalallah".

It would have been better if we had this talk face to face. As for my Phone number kindly refer 'contact us' link of Akhbari website wherein my complete address and phone number is given

Wassalaam

Saelebabul Yaqeen Syed Waheeduddin Hyder Jaffery Akhbari.
 


Date          :Thu 19 Aug2004
From     :Shaban Ali (shabanali52@yahoo.com)

Subject : Question To :saelebabulyaqeen@akhbari.org

Salamunalaikum. I have studied akhbari view.I would like you to solve my one queri. Question : Akhbaris believe that there are changes and alterations (Tehreef) made in Quran,and as an evidence they give reference of Dua "Sanama e quresh" Question is "How will it be possible to examine ahadees of Masoomeen a.s. in the light of (tempered and altered) Quran ? Wassalam. With regards from your brother in Islam.

 

Date        :Sun 28 Nov 2004
To           :
Shaban Ali (shabanali52@yahoo.com)
Subject    :Re: Question
From       :saelebabulyaqeen@akhbari.org

 

Bismillah Hir Rehman Nir Raheem

Salamun Alaikum

Janab Shaban Ali Sahab

It would have been better if you had decided about which sect you belong to so that this question would not have arised in your mind. For your heart's satisfaction and deciding about the religion, i am giving you an Ayat from Quran from which you will also get proof for dua e sanamae quraish.

Ayat 79 Tafseer 1 Surae Waqiya

 ''La Yamasahu...'' ... Tahzeeb ul ehkam mein Janab Imam Moosiye Kazim(AS) se manqool hai ke mushaf ko napaak honeki halat mein na chuhwa jaaye aur janb honeki halat mein na chuhwa jaye aur na latkaya jaye ke uski dori chuhwi jaye aur na uske aur mutaleqhaat. isliye ke khuda farmata hai ''la tamasahu...'' ... ehtejaaje tabresi mein hai ke jab umar abubakr ki taraf se khaleefa banaya gaya to us ne Janabe Amir(AS) se darqhaast ki ke woh Hazrat(AS) apna quran-e-majeed awaam un naas ko de dein taake un logoun mein jo quran raaej tha us se milakar dekh len. un Hazrat(AS) se guftagoo in lafzoun mein ki '' aye Abulhasan(AS) agar aap munasib jaaney to woh quran le aayein jo abubakar ke saamne laye the taake hum sab ka uspar ijtemaa ho jaaye'' . Hazrat(AS) ne farmaya: Afsos ab uske milne ka tumhare liye koi mouqha nahi hai. Abubakar ke paas usko is liye laya tha ke tum par hujjat hojaaye aur tum qayamat ke din yeh na keh sako ke tum is se bekhabar the. na yeh keh sako ke aap usey hamare paas laye na the. warna jo quran-e-majeed mere paas hai usey to siwaye mutaharoun ke yaani ausiya ke jo meri aulad se honge aur koi chooh bhi nahi sakta. Umar ne kaha aaya us ke izhaar ka koi waqt bhi muyyaan hai?   Hazrat(AS) ne farmaya : haan, maloom hai jab meri aulad mein se Qayam Aale Md(AS) qayam honge woh usko zahir bhi karenge aur sab logoun ko usi par chalayenge aur tamaam qawaid qawaneen usi ke mutabiqh jaari honge.

Since you have asked for it, here is the answer, Masoom(as) says that "Quran is a miracle of God" whose apparent proof is that even after being altered ahadees are matching with Quran. Besides this Masoom(as) orders us to match their ahadees with Quran and if we are unable to do so then recite it on sick person (mareez per dum kardo).

wassalam

Saelebabul Yaqeen

Syed Waheeduddin Hyder Jaffery Akhbari


Date          :Mon 20 Sep 2004
From      :imran hyder (sayedimranhyder@yahoo.com)

Subject :Ya Alli Madad To :saelebabulyaqeen@akhbari.org

Ya Alli Madad Sarkar

My name is Syed Imran Hyder Taqvi

I am from Pakistan. Sir before visiting your site I had no information about Akhbari and Usooli shia.

But i always hated Muqasreen and Munkareen-e-Willayat and Azadari.

I saw your site on net and i really was very happy to see your aqeeda. And I have told many of friends to visit your site. And they all are very happy to see it. Here there are some Allama who are fighting against Muqasreen, but there is no any site. Sir There are few questions in my mind I want to ask you.

1. What is meant be Akhbari?

2. Tell me the web site name of Usooli?

3. can a Sayyeda women get marry with non-Sayed?

4. What do you know about Aqeeda of Khumeni?

Bar Muqasreen Lanat      Bar Abu-Bakar and his company Lanat

Syed Imran Hyder

Pakistan

 

Date    : Sun 28 Nov 2004
To       :
imran hyder (sayedimranhyder@yahoo.com)
Sub    : Re:Ya Alli Madad
From  : saelebabulyaqeen@akhbari.org

 

Bismillah Hir Rehmaan Nir Raheem

Salamun Alaikum

Janab Syed Imran Hyder Taqvi sahab, may God keep you on Imaan. We, the true Shias are going through such turbulent times that even if one person of same faith comes across it seems like two brothers meeting after a long separation.

(1) Meaning of Akhbari-- Follower of Akhbar-e-Elahiya(Quran, Hadees-e-Qudsi)  and Akhbar-e-Masoomeen(as)'s sayings is called an Akhbari. Also refer Ferozul Lughath.

(2) Name of Usooli website---- Who's father is not known, how can I tell the name of their site.

(3) can a Sayyeda women get marry with non-Sayed? ----- Shehzadi Zainab (sw)'s marriage to Hazrat Abdullah (as) is the proof.

(4)What do you know about Aqeeda of Khumeni?----- Head of the naari sect (those who will go to hell) .

Wassalaam

Saelebabul Yaqeen

Syed Waheeduddin Hyder Jaffery Akhbari.


Date         :Wed,10 Nov 2004
From     :arif baqari (ariftopi2000@yahoo.co.in)

Subject : Akhbari kutta ke Bacche To :saelebabulyaqeen@akhbari.org
Are, Waheed,

Gandu ki Aulad, Yeh kya Khoum me FASAD Barpa kya hai tu ne, Akhbari ka.  Abe agar apni Khair chata hai tu Khamoosh bait ja, warna teri tu accha nahi hooga, 

Arif Topi.

Date         :Sun, 28 Nov 2004
From     :
saelebabulyaqeen@akhbari.org
To :
arif baqari (ariftopi2000@yahoo.co.in)
Bismillah Hir Rehman Nir Raheem
Aali janab mohtarram Arif topi sahab

Khudawande Aalam aapko nek taufeeq ataa farmaye. Kaash ke jo alfaaz aapne mere liye 

istemaal kiye hai unke liye karte jo aalame daura fitna aur fisaad barpa karne ke liye

Alian Waliullah ko jusve Azaan na hai, aur Khooni matam o Alam-e-Mubarak ki istadgi

ke khilaaf wo nis aqaaid-e-shiat ke khilaaf fatawe de rahe hai. Aapne jo dhamki di hai

ye to daure masabaq se hota hi hua aaraha hai, humko iski parwa nahi hai. Magar aapse 

guzarish hai ke aap ka sahi naam mai waldiyat wo pata tehreer farmaye to mai ye samjhunga

waqayatan aap apne marja ke maanne waale hai.
Salamun alaa manit tabeulhuda

Saelababul yaqeen Syed Waheeduddin Hyder Jaffery Akhbari.


Date      :Mon 19 Jul 2004
From     :Zakiya abedi (sza_26@yahoo.co.in)

Subject :Helloo
To         :akhbariqueries@akhbari.org

cc        :saelebabulyaqeen@akhbari.org

 

Asalam Alaikum Wa Rahematullah Hi Wa Barkatahu

Waheed Uncle,

I juzz wanted to know the names of all the wifes of all the 11 Imams ..n the names of all their childrens in order...

And yes i went to your site esp the differences between akhbari n usuli....n i was shocked to read the differences n i didnt even find 1 right differences....n yes on the Day Of Ashura u mean tht usuli's dont do khooni matam n akhbari's do..i never ever heard about this...or is tht u mean tht all thoses Anjumans who right from 8th of mohorram do KHOONI MATAM are all AKHBARIS ...n not even a single usuli...i never even heard of a seprate Anjuman -e- Akhbari...n yes this akhbari started just recently what about the peoples who are doing khooni matam through out moharram from all this years????...instead of saying peoples to pray namaaz regularly n follow all USUL -E- DIIN and FOURO -E- DIIN...u are simply creating hatred between shia bhai bhai...i dont understand what are you peoples getting from all this things and why are you peoples doing this??????

Khuda Hafiz....N hopeing that you will reply me as soon as possible...

 

Date      :Tue 24 Aug 2004
From     :Zakiya abedi (sza_26@yahoo.co.in)

Subject :Re:hello
To         :akhbariqueries@akhbari.org

 

As Salaam Alaikum

i feel u dont know the answer thtz why you are delaying to reply me...

 

Date      :Tue 29 Dec 2004
From     :
akhbariqueries@akhbari.org
Subject :Re: Helloo
To         :
Zakiya abedi (sza_26@yahoo.co.in)
 

Bismillah Hir Rahman Nir Raheem
Mohterama Zakiya Abedi Saheba, Salamunalaikum,

 1)       Read Chaharda Sitarey you will get all the details.
2)       The differences we gave on our website, if they are wrong as per your research then give the proof in the light of Quran & Hadees else I have your marajas Tauziul Masael from which I can prove Usooli Sects beliefs (Aqaed) and practices which are against Shiism. If you think that during mourning usoolis also are doing Khooni Matam then they are acting against their marajae (mujtahadeens) fatwa. This is something you should think about. For Akhbaris Khooni Matam is Ibadath. Secondly, Akhbarism isnt new but I can give you proof about usoolism being new which is working like wahabis to kill Shia Imamia Ithna Ashari (Akhbari) religion.

In your religion Usool-e-deen are 5, usoole islam 3, usoole mazhab 2i.e Imamat & Adl. And your marja ayatullah khoi in his Touzeeul Masael writes- if one doesnt accept Imamat & Adl, he will still remain Muslim. Do take note of this Aqeeda, time to think about, time to think, time to think.
Furu-e-deen in your religion are only 6 refer latest usooli sects new Tohfatul awaam.
Keep this always in your mind that your hearing about something, only ,is Ilm/fact. NO. Like you wrote that you havent heard about (anjumane) Akhbari till now.

Lastly since you have called me uncle here is an advice for my niece to save her from hell: - remove all prejudices and anti Akhbariism thorn from your mind and keep your mind cool and go through our, Shia Imamia Ithna Ashari Akhbaris website in detail and read carefully.

And in your second mail you wrote that I didnt know the answers thatz why im not replying, you have done Qiyas here and you should know that Awwalamman qiyasa wa hua Iblis . For your information not only Akhbari website but from Minmbars also we have been continuously challenging Usooli Ulema, Mujtahadeens, Zakereen to answer our questions but till today all are answerless this is a FACT and not qiyas. And whichever mujtahid you follow, do get answers to our queries from him.

Wassalam
Saelebabul Yaqeen Syed Waheeduddin Hyder Jaffery Akhbari


Date      :Mon 10 May 2004
From     :suhailhyderkhan@yahoo.com

Subject :Shahadat or Wafat
To         :akhbariqueries@akhbari.org

Allah HO Akber     Qayam Hain Rahber
Salamalaikum 
Dear brother in Iman

Hope you are fine by the blessing of Allah and Masomeen (as). I wanted to know is it shahdaat or wafat of Prophet Mohammad (swa). Because if it is shahdaat then please do send me proof so that I can show it to some shia wahabis here. And if it is wafat then answer me. Prophet (swa) is Masoom and an Alim. A person dies only when his ilem fails and he do not know what has happend to him.
Waiting for your reply.   Kudahafiz
Suhail hyder khan        Madras


Date      :Tue 29 Dec 2004
From     :
akhbariqueries@akhbari.org
Subject :Re: shahadat or wafaat
To         : suhailhyderkhan@yahoo.com

Bismillah Hir Rahman Nir Raheem
Salamunalaikum Janab Suhail Shab,

Allah o Akbar       Qayam e Ajallahotala Faraju Rehbar
When one momin dies, Masoom(as) says for him Man maata ala hubbey aaley Mohammadin faqad maata shaheeda even if he died on his sickbed, he dies as a shaheed. Then how come this question arose in any Shias mind, that whether Prophet Mohammed (sw) is Shaheed or not? Shahdat is one of the main attributes of Masoomeen (as).

Wassalam
Saele Babul Yaqeen Syed Waheeduddin Hyder Jaffery Akhbari
 


 Date      :Sat 26 Jan 2004
From     :
Mustafa Sayyed (mustafasayyed2003@yahoo.co.in)
Subject :need urgent help
To         :akhbariqueries@akhbari.org
                                                               

as salaam valekum,hi i got married on 5Th of jan 2004 arranged married. it was my 2nd marriage,as well my mrs 2nd marriage.we don,t have any children from ours 1st marriage. soon after a months problem arise.       as mymrs  went to attend some function shecaught hold of witch,as per my mom n law says, i don ,t believe inthis. soon my life became miserable,they held responsible for me. they spread the rumour ki i had sex  with my wife during her menses,which is utter rubish. the bottom line is that she is suffering from sexually transmitted disease, but my wife is not disclosing it ,she loves me  & i too love her i don,t want to miss her in my life.after evey 15-20 days she falls sick,some sort of boora saya is behind her as per the knowledge of my wife nd mom n law.we on couple of occassion went to hazarat mira dattar dargah.my mom n law take her to daugther when she is at her resi to mollah,she burns lemon,tied tavis n d what not. i am in confussion plz advice. what r the remedy to live alive n d start our life

Date      :Tue 29 Dec 2004
From     :
akhbariqueries@akhbari.org
Subject :Re:
To         :
Mustafa Sayyed (mustafasayyed2003@yahoo.co.in)

Bismillah Hir Rahman Nir Raheem
Salamun Alaikum Janab Mustafa Sahab

Your query is no way related to religion but I will help you as a fellow human being. For this you will have to provide me complete birth details of you both and also in which month you were married. If you live in Hyderabad, contact me personally.

Wassalam
Saele Babul Yaqeen Syed Waheeduddin Hyder Jaffery
 


Date      :Fri 7 May 2004
From     :
Munazza Abedi (munazza_78600@yahoo.com)
Sub       :
Hi..i have a question
To         :akhbariqueries@akhbari.org
 

Asalamwalaykum..Hi my name is Munazza Abedi. I am Shia Ithna Asheri..I am also Syed..ok this is the first time I'm hearing about Akbaris and Usoolis..I didn't know tat Shiism also had these 2 sects..Ok I don't know a thing about akhbaris or usoolis..I don't even know if I'm an akhbari or usooli and I mite not be either...I've heard 99.9% of Abedis are Akhbari...ok will u plzz tell me more about the Akhbaris and wat separates them from regular ithna asheri shias...I'm soo confused and I would like to find out wat I am...I don't know If Im Akhbari or not..So I would really appreciate it if u replied....

Date      :Tue 29 Dec 2004
From     :
akhbariqueries@akhbari.org
Subject :Re:
To         :
Munazza Abedi (munazza_78600@yahoo.com)

Bismillah Hir Rahman Nir Raheem
Salamunalaikum Munazza Saheba,

Religion is known by its customs and practices, If you are acting only upon Masoomeen(as)s traditions then you are definitely  Shia-ne-Ali(as), Ithnaashari, Imamia, Akhbari,Rafzi, Jaffery. And if you are not doing so then you are neither a Shia nor Ithnaashari nor Imamia nor Akhbari nor Rafzi and neither Jaffery. Please go through the website carefully and in detail, you will know the difference about who the real Shia-ne-Ali (as) are. 

Wassalam
Saele Babul Yaqeen Syed Waheeduddin Hyder Jaffery


Date      :Mon 10 May 2004
From     :
Waseem Zaidi (waseem_zaidi@hotmail.com
Sub       :salam

To         :akhbariqueries@akhbari.org
 

A'Salam U'Alaikum Warahmatullah WaBarakatuhu
Hadiya ya Ali a.s maddad
1st of all i want to say congratulation to built so nice and informative site and secondly another congrates that u have built a plateform for the peoplees who were not gethared at a point , but thare are some more needs to publish and circulate this thing in shia  community , and peple of all over the world specially pakistan , and one thing more that if you are running some kind of maddrasa then , send us detail .
Allah hafiz      take care     Thanx soo much 4 ur time
YA ALI MADAD
Khuda Hafiz

Date      :Tue 29 Dec 2004
From     :
akhbariqueries@akhbari.org
Subject :Re:
To         :
Waseem Zaidi (waseem_zaidi@hotmail.com)

Bismillah Hir Rehman Nir Raheem
Salamun Alaikum  Janab Waseem Zaidi Sahab

We are thankful to you for your encouragement. We are trying to spread the truth as much as it is possible for us and our website is the prime example of our efforts. Secondly, in our sermons too we try to make Momeneen understand what the truth (haq) is and what wrong (batil) is. But it is every Momins duty to spread the truth as much as he can. In Hyderabad our Madrasa is Darsgaah-e-Akhbar e Aaley Md(sw) being run under Alavi Educational Society (Regd.). In it taalebaat are taught Quran & Ahadees by Mudaraseen. Pray that this school runs smoothly and maintains high standards.

Wassalam
Saele Babul Yaqeen Syed Waheeduddin Hyder Jaffery


Date          :Wed 18 Aug2004

From         :bashir75 (bashirahmed75@yahoo.com)

Subject     :

To            :saelebabulyaqeen@akhbari.org 

ya ali madad. i got one hadith from ur introduction page,that was of 73 firqa in the ummat of holy prophet,only one will go to paradise,becuse of wilayat e ammer.i like it so much,i heard only half of first ,so i must need its reference because of people must wana get reference,i believe every hadith which tells the fazeelat of my moula,i dont need its reference but for the people,they will not accept it without reference. so pls reply me as soon as possible. waiting, bashir ya ali madad.and salam to all of you,who do service for wilayat e ameer(a.s).

 

Date      :Tue 29 Dec 2004
From     :
saelebabulyaqeen@akhbari.org
Subject :Re:
To         :
bashir75 (bashirahmed75@yahoo.com)

 

Bismillah Hir Rehman Nir Raheem
Salamun alaikum Janab Basheer Ahmed Sahab

Whoever is asking you reference please narrate Prophet Younus (as) incident. Since you have asked for reference I m giving you two for you gaining knowledge.
1)Ad da-e-ul Amr fi Ehkaamul Ai-imma and
2) Sura-e-Al Aeraaf, Ayat 179, read tafseer  by Moulana  Marhoom Syed Maqbool Ahmed Sahab(ra). 

 Wassalam
Saele Babul Yaqeen Syed Waheeduddin Hyder Jaffery


Date          :Fri 21 May 2004
From         :
Musa (cafermed@yahoo.com)
Subject     :x
To            :akhbariqueries@akhbari.org
 

Assalamu alaykum
Ya Ali Madad

Thanx very much for this site. It's a very good and eye_opener site for momeneen. I believe in akhbari aqedah, however I need some points to be explained. Please do not take these as offence, I just wanted to learn more, I'm afraid of asking people something because they are whether usooli or I do not know their views about akhbaris.
1) Would you please clarify the issue of tahreef of Quran? What changes made? (For example, deletion of verses, changing the order of verses, changing words, changing the correct recitation,...) Do akhbaris have a belief that: "We believe x number of ayats or such and such ayats have been deleted." How do akhbaris explain the ayat(meaning): "We descended it and we'll protect it." (Some tafseers mention that this protection is to prevent shaytan from divine revelation, is this the correct tafseer?) Any tafseer from Ahlulbayt? What do our holy imams (as) say about this topic?
2) Would our farz namaz not be invalid if we recite a surah which has verses missing?  Did the imams(as) give icazat to recite any surah? 
3) Some say that since tea and coffee is not drunk by momeneen in the era of Imams(as)(except of course living Imam Hz. Hujjat(a.f.)), akhbaris do not drink them as a matter of precaution. Is this true? If true, what are other things which we must know?
4) We believe in musawat of masomeen(as), but sometimes I come across some ahadith which seem opposite. ( Clearly saying that Rasuli Akram do(s.a.a.) is the best man ever and then Amirulmomeneen(as) and then other Eimme(as).) What you say about them? Are they all mavdoo?
5) In my area, all other people I know are whether usooli or sunni or zindiq. I shouldn't pray behind usooli imams, is this true? When I will be obliged to pay khums and zakat( a few years later maybe), what should I do?
6) Except from the tashahhud, are there other things different in prayers and related things? Is the salaam after tashahhud the same?
7) As far as I understand from ahadith, all kinds of music are haram. Am I right?
8) What are the rulings about organ donation, dissection of corpses for medical and judicial reasons?
9) What is the ruling about Juma prayers during the time of major occultation?

Date      :Sun 2nd Jan 2005
From     :
akhbariqueries@akhbari.org
Subject :Re:x
To         :
Musa (cafermed@yahoo.com)

Bismillah Hir Rahman Nir Raheem

Salamunalaikum Janab Musa Sahab,

1) For Tehreef/ changes in Quran Page 857 Ayat 79 Tafseer 1 Surae Waqiya
 ''la yamasahu...'' ... Tahzeeb ul ehkam mein Janb Imam Moosiye Kazim(AS) se manqool hai ke mushaf ko napaak honeki halat mein na chuhwa jaaye aur janb honeki halat mein na chuhwa jaye aur na latkaya jaye ke uski dori chuhwi jaye aur na uske aur mutaleqhaat. isliye ke khuda farmata hai ''la yamasahu...'' ... ehtejaaje tabresi mein hai ke jab umar abubakr ki taraf se khaleefa banaya gaya to us ne Janabe Amir(AS) se darqhaast ki ke woh Hazrat(AS) apna quran-e-majeed awaam un naas ko de dein taake un logoun mein jo quran raaej tha us se milakar dekh len. un Hazrat(AS) se guftagoo in lafzoun mein ki '' aye Abulhasan(AS) agar aap munasib jaaney to woh quran le aayein jo abubakar ke saamne laye the taake hum sab ka uspar ijtemaa ho jaaye'' . Hazrat(AS) ne farmaya: Afsos ab uske milne ka tumhare liye koi mouqha nahi hai. Abubakar ke paas usko is liye laya tha ke tum par hujjat hojaaye aur tum qayamat ke din yeh na keh sako ke tum is se bekhabar the. na yeh keh sako ke aap usey hamare paas laye na the. warna jo quran-e-majeed mere paas hai usey to siwaye mutaharoun ke yaani ausiya ke jo meri aulad se honge aur koi chooh bhi nahi sakta. Umar ne kaha aaya us ke izhaar ka koi waqt bhi muyyaan hai?   Hazrat(AS) ne farmaya : haan, maloom hai jab meri aulad mein se Qayam Aale Md(AS) qayam honge woh usko zahir bhi karenge aur sab logoun ko usi par chalayenge aur tamaam qawaid qawaneen usi ke mutabiqh jaari honge.   

2) Imam (as) has told us to follow this Quran

3) Khala Rasool(sw): Jo mazkoor nahi hai who matloob nahi hai that which is not given will not be asked. 

4) Ahadees: La tajebu ya qoumun Ana Aliun wo Aliun Ana
Fa Khalal Imam (as): La Tajebu min qudrattillah Ana Mohammadun wa Mohammadun Ana In view of Masoomeen (as)s sayings we should not wonder. Due to their posts sometimes in our minds such thoughts come, to get rid of such thoughts we should learn by heart the above ahadees or this one Awwalona Mohammed (sw), Aakherona Mohammed (sw), Ausadona Mohammed (sw) Wa kullona Mohammed (sw).

5) Furo e Kaafi: It was asked to Imam Md.Baqar (as)
(a) about namaz which is read behind Muqalafeen (adversary/ enemy) Replied, For me, those people are like walls.      
(b) If differences occur between your friends (mawali) should I read namaz behind all of them? Imam (as) replied behind those whose faith/religion you trust.  
Abi Abdullah (as) said: If one is not Arif then his Azan recital is not correct. A Muslim man and Arif e Azaan should read Azaan and if he knows all the Arkaan(essentials) of Azaan then he should recite. If he does not have Marefat of Azaan then neither is his Azaan enough nor his Aqama and they are not fit to be taken account of.
Note: In view of these Ahadees you yourself think, in whose, religion and maslak, among Arkaan Azaan the basic essential Rukn Alian Waliullah is not taken as Juz (integral Part) of Azaan, and when one Moazzans (One who recites Azan) Azan and Aqama are not being counted/considered then how will Namaz behind such Pesh Namaz be called right? And when the means to Marefate Allah is Imam (as) and not Rasool (sw).

Imam (as) orders for payment of Khums are that it should be given to Syed, look for the needy and fulfill your Wajib. For Zakaat, whoever is needy in your eyes pay him.

6) Clarify about Tashahud and which Tashahud do you read?

7) Yes

9)
Juma: Mustadrakul Wasael Page 458
Ameerul Momeneen (as) says: Islah nahi paata koi faisla (hukum), hudood aur Juma baghair e Imam (as) ke saath.
Order (judgment), punishment and Juma (Friday prayer) are not correct without Imam (as)s presence.

Wassalam
Saele Babul Yaqeen Syed Waheeduddin Hyder Jaffery Akhbari
 


Date          :Tue 4 May 2004
From         :
maadi villa (maadivilla@hotmail.com)
Subject     :please help
To            :akhbariqueries@akhbari.org
 

Dear Akhbari Sight:
Hello, my name is Sayyid Fareed; my family is Westernized, and living here in the United states.I am trying to find the correct sunnah! We our family is originally from SouthEast Asia; India.My father tells me we are Akhbari shias. I have been having discussions with Americans; who have told me that in their newspapers, it says that Ayatullah Khoei is a "good" Shia, from Iraq, called Akhbari. They've told me that Ayatullah Seestani is also a good type Akhbari Shia.They say AsSadar is a "bad" (like Iranian) Shia, because he is Usuli. They also say the same of Ayatullah Herari?? Please, I can find no information who to believe on this point?Who is a true Akhbari Shia, and a true Usuli Shia? Also, is it okay, to use taqiyyah, to conceal the truth from my American coworkers, if I think the information will be harmful?I don't know who to believe on this; as to what fiqh the Ayatullah's Seesanti, Khoei and Herari are; and also AsSadr? Please help!!

Sincerely, Yours
Sayyid Fareed

Date      :Thu Dec 30 2004
From     :
akhbariqueries@akhbari.org
Subject :Re:please help
To         :
maadi villa (maadivilla@hotmail.com)

Bismillah Hir Rahman Nir Raheem
Salamunalaikum Janab Sayyid Fareed Sahab,

Sistani, Khoi.... all are usooli because their sources of law are 4 - Quran, Hadees, Aql and Ijma . In truth a person whose sources of Law are 4 can never be a Shia (refer the books Mohammadan Law written by B S Varma 5th edition-the Shias reject the first 3 caliphs they naturally reject Ijma as source of Law) Refer Seestani's Amalya-Touzeeul Masael" ch.Taqleed in it he writes sources of law are 4. When he is writing sources of law as 4 how can he be a Shia?? In the same Amalya, for difference in Fatwas (by different persons) star mark is used. Point to note is when Deen/religion is same then how come solutions (fr masael) differ??? 

Wassalam
Saelebabulyaqeen Syed Waheeduddin Hyder Jaffery AKhbari


Date          :Sun 13 Jun 2004
From         :
ali reza" (sajjad2alireza@yahoo.co.in)

Subject     :
To            :akhbariqueries@akhbari.org
 

Name of the book BIHAR UL ANWAAR Allamma mulla mohammed Baqir majalisi Arabic Vol 52 53 , Urdu Vol 12
Dar haalate Imam e Zamana Bab 31
Tawqee of Imam in reply to Ishaaq bin Yaaqub via second deputy Mohammed bin Usman :
Aur Khums yeh to mai apne shio kay liyay mubah karta hu aur yeh mere zuhoor e amr tak unke liyay Halal hai taki unki wiladat paak ho aur gandagi na ho.
Also in Ghaibate Tusi and Kamaluddin.This clearly states that Khums is mubah not wajib.
Salamoon ALAIKUM

I have heard that there is a Hadith of Imam Sadiq as that Khums is only on what u earn without any effort (i.e war booty, treasure ot on earnings) Kya Imam hamara mehnat ka khayegy? Pls aans along with refrence in english

Date      :Thu Dec 30 2004
From     :
akhbariqueries@akhbari.org
Subject :
To         :
ali reza" (sajjad2alireza@yahoo.co.in)

Bismillah Hir Rehman Nir Raheem
Salamun alaikum Janab Ali Raza Sahab,

Imam (as) says that Usoole kafi, hamare Shiaoun ke liye Kaafi Hai. Keeping this in mind when I read Usoole Kaafi I found these Ahadees on what Imam(as) said about Khums.
Khums: - Usoole Kaafi, Kitabul Hujjat. Abu Abdullah (as) said: do you know how adultery seeps into peoples lives?  I replied, I do not know. Said, by not paying our (Ahlebait.as) Khums, but those of our Shias who pay Khums their children are born Halaal.

There is a narration related to Imam Jaffer-e-Sadiq (as) that Judgement Day will be very hard on everyone, there Saheb-e-Khums i.e Imam (as) will stand and ask, O Parwardigar (God) My Khums? That is he will claim his right.
Imam (as) also says that we have made Khums Paak for our Shias so that their birth is cleansed (Paak aur Saaf Wiladat).

Note: In view of this Ahadees you yourself decide whether Khums is to be given or not. Because in this Hadees Imam (as) is saying Aye mere Parwardigar, mera khums? If Imam (as) had waived it then wy will he ask Allah for his Khums?

Note: Further answers you have asked for are being put on hold until you tell us your Maslak, because we answer only true Shias i.e.Akhbaris.

Wassalam
Saele Babul Yaqeen Syed Waheeduddin Hyder Jaffery Akhbari


Date          :Sat 19 Jun 2004
From         :
Haider abbas (abbasnajfi@yahoo.com)
Subject     :
khums and eid prayers
To            :saelebabulyaqeen@akhbari.org
 

hello sir !   salaam-un-alikum and ya Ali madad!
   I want to ask u about the book kashful haqaiq'written by seyad baqir nisar zaidy of Pakistan.he also belongs to akhbari maslak but he says that khums is right of hazrat baqiyatullah(a.s).They shell come and ricive their right withc is the right of Allah taala and Imam and sadaats.In this age of their ghaibat it should not be paid to any one.he also says that juma namaz is haraam without iqtidaa of Imam (a,s)and same the Eid prayers are haraamin disapearance of imam (a.s).He gives the refrance of Allah taala and Imam and sadaats.In this age of their ghaibat it should not be paid to any one.he also says that juma namaz is haraam without iqtidaa of Imam (a,s)and same the Eid prayers are haraamin disapearance of imam (a.s).He gives the refrance of saheefah-e-sajadia dua-e-Imam Zinulaabideen(a.s)and hadees -e- Masoomeen.U can see this book online on shiabooks.org.from where may we get risallah -e- ahkaam fiq akhabieen

 thanx a lot             Abbas raza saqy         Pakistan

Date      :Thu Dec 30 2004
From     :
akhbariqueries@akhbari.org
Subject :
khums and eid prayers
To         :
Haider abbas (abbasnajfi@yahoo.com)

Bismillah Hir Rehman Nir Raheem
Salamun alaikum Janab Abbas Raza Saqy Sahab,

For Baquer Nisar Zaidi:-
1) Khums: - Usoole Kaafi, Kitabul Hujjat. Abu Abdullah (as) said: do you know how adultery seeps into peoples lives?  I replied, I do not know. Said, by not paying our (Ahlebait.as) Khums, but those of our Shias who pay Khums their children are born Halaal.
There is a narration related to Imam Jaffer-e-Sadiq (as) that Judgement Day will be very hard on everyone, there Saheb-e-Khums i.e Imam (as) will stand and ask, O Parwardigar (God) My Khums? That is he will claim his right.
Imam (as) also says that we have made Khums Paak for our Shias so that their birth is cleansed (Paak aur Saaf Wiladat).

Note: In view of this Ahadees you yourself decide whether Khums is to be given or not. Because in this Hadees Imam (as) is saying Aye mere Parwardigar, mera khums? If Imam (as) had waived it then wy will he ask Allah for his Khums?

2)Eid Prayers: Man la Yahzarahul Faqih Jild 1 Page 289.Hadees no.1476
Abubasir narrates that Hzt.Imam Jaffer e- Sadiq (as) said : If you are going to travel (leave one place to go to other) and if Fajar time has come then do not leave the city you are in till you have attended Eid prayers there.

3)Juma: Mustadrakul Wasael Page 458
Ameerul Momeneen (as) says: Islah nahi paata koi faisla (hukum), hudood aur Juma baghair e Imam (as) ke saath.
Order (judgment), punishment and Juma (Friday prayer) are not correct without Imam (as)s presence.
Note: In this Hadees Moula (as) has not put any conditions regarding Imam (as)s presence for Eid Prayers. 

Wassalam
Saele Babul Yaqeen Syed Waheeduddin Hyder Jaffery Akhbari

Inshallah, this link Will be updated on regular basis.....keep visiting


Copyright2003 www.akhbari.com. All rights reserved